The roundup I’ve been putting off for ages is here! Today I’m sharing the best and worst tubing mascaras. I love tubing mascaras because they act like a waterproof mascara, but with the easiest rinse off and no eye rubbing. But a lot of factors go into a really great tubing formula – today you’ll learn why my favorites are my favorites, and what tubing mascara formula is right for you!
Tubing Mascaras Mentioned:
Glossier Lash Slick:
Em Cosmetics Mascara:
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara:
Hard Candy Ultimate Extension Mascara:
Victoria Beckham Beauty Mascara:
Hourglass Unlocked Mascara:
Blinc Volume Mascara:
What else is on my face:
Fenty Body Sauce (1):
Fenty Eaze Drop (2):
Rare Beauty Concealer (130N):
Patrick Ta Bronzer Duo (She’s Statuesque):
Pat McGrath Divine Blush (Divine Rose, Nymphette, Fleurtatious):
Thrive Causemetics Perfect Eye Palette Warm Neutrals:
Glossier Boy Brow (Brown):
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara (Crystal):
Thrive Causemetics Lip Filler Lip Liner in Kackie:
Other Discount Links:
20% off at ATHR Beauty: (Code HEYKACKIE)
50% your Italic Membership: (code KACKIE50)
$25 off at Daily Harvest:
$15 off at Jungmaven: RWRD.IO/J4Z6JZP
30% off Bundles at Salt New York: code (KACKIE30)
10% off at Glossier:
10% off at Thrive Causemetics:
15% off at Farfetch:
20% off at ICONOLAB: Use code KACKIE
1 month FREE at Rocksbox:
$2,500 off your complete smile makeover at The Cosmetic Dentists of Austin: Mention my name on your first call!
FTC disclosure: This video is not sponsored, but some items have been gifted. This video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links.
This was just all over the place.
Nothing says “cruelty free” like a fake deer head trophy hanging in the background.
Great video! Thank you
Thank you for this!!! ❤️❤️
Tubing mascaras also don’t work as well in very humid climates. I used the Thrive in Mexico and regretted it. My curl dropped and the tubes came off all over my face.
Thank you for reminding me my Thrive mascara is like 16 months old. Just ordered a fresh one! 😬
The cruelty free thing is so hard especially when you mention Clinique. I have a few products that I cannot find replacements for anywhere else that's cruelty free so I keep using it but I feel bad every time I do.
Fantastic video!!! Thank you!!!
You are so going to make me try the VB mascara. I usually keep my thrive for quick big lashes and glossier for a softer more natural lash. If you like the curved wand and want a standard mascara that doesn’t smudge or flake and washes off pretty easily – with the wander beauty unlashed a try!
I've heard that the LA Girl Volumatic Mascara is an affordable tubing mascara. I haven't tried it yet, but I'd be interested to hear you review it
The Victoria Beckham brush looks a lot like the CLIO mascara brush. I need to try the Thrive mascara.
Where is the ring on your right middle finger from!!!??!
This was so helpful, thank you so much for making it!
I went into Ulta to get a new mascara and asked about “tubing mascaras”…sales lady made me feel like I was making up a word lol.
Velour lashes has a new tubing mascara that I love! And they are cruelty free!
Hi! It might be worth giving the OG DHC Double Protection and the Sensai Lash Volumiser 38C mascaras a go! Would love to see what you think
This is such a weird thing to say but you have the WHITEST teeth haha
For lower lashes try MAC Gigablack Mascara. It’s got a tiny wand and it’s a tubing, very black mascara. Perfection on the lower lashes. Next on my must have is the Thrive Mascara. But, I will say, a friend sent me a mascara from Japan, Sendai Mascara 38 Grad Vol 01 Black. It was amazing. Not tubing but it didn’t smear, smudge or flake and water resistant. It was amazing. Unfortunately it retails in the US for $49.00+. So, it was a once in a lifetime treat.
My fav tubing ones aside from the Japanese ones is — Kevin Aucoin! It's amazeballs ❤️ best American one in my opinion. I'd love for you to review it.
I was really concerned that Thrive mascara would be de-throned… ha! Always love hearing your recommendations!
Which was your 5 best tubing mascara among cruelty free and non cruelty free?
she hot
I’ve never tried a tubing mascara, but after this video… think I need too! Thank you Kackie!
I have loved my L'Oreal Beauty Tubes, on one side is a primer to build volume first, and its under $12 Canadian dollars
which one do you feel holds the best curl?
Kackie, I would love to hear your thoughts on Velour tubing mascara!
my life is forever changed by the inttoduction of tubing mascaras to my life – thank you!
"No tolerance for smudging & never heard of a tubing formula"…raises hand. My old mascara dried up so it was time to try another. The other day decided to try a sample size of (lancome's monsuier big) before going to someone's house for dinner. BIG mistake! Its horrible for my smallish eyes! It smudged all over my top lid & even the bottom (even though I didn't do my bottom lashes). Then I tried clean my lid & it made it worse. I had to remove all eye makeup & start over. Good thing I got that mascara for free! I mentioned my story in another YTuber's video & she suggest tubing mascaras. Now here I am trying to figure out what's it all about.
Thanks Kackie! There’s also Sensai 38 mascara, which is also a tubing mascara. They have like 3 or 4 of them with different properties. And Sweed lashes mascara also claims to have tubing technology
I like the OLD version of original Blinc. I recently bought a new one and the formula has changed after years of it working perfectly now its not as perfect. They dont give you the outer container to keep the air out anymore and its not as good. The volume one from blinc is not my fav and def not great esp when its old and dry like yours. Blinc you really need to keep them sealed up.
I'm so funny I find that the thrive is so hard to come off. I need help getting it off.
Thank you so much im going to try Victoria B
I HATED the thrive mascara and I know that's an unpopular opinion but its SO clumpy to the point where it looks like I took a trip back to the early 2000's where everyone just put a ton of coats on. If you want that effect after ONE application then get the thrive mascara lol. I used to use Perversion by urban decay but I'm trying to fin a clean beauty option because I have sensitive skin and I noticed during quarantine when i was wearing like no make up that my eye lashes got way longer. This is presumably because the perversion was causing breakage from wearing it daily. I hardly wear make up now but when I do i only wear mascara. So on my hunt still!
Does the VB mascara hold curl?🤔
May I ask why you can't say the brand Merit? I got lost there 😅
Thank you, Kackie – can’t get Thrive where I am so went with the Hourglass. I had been looking for a mascara that wouldn’t smudge (I have oily lids) but was also easy to remove. Did not even know about tubing mascaras before this video. Game changer!!
I love Thrive but always lose it. I like everything about it except the fact that the packaging looks bad after a week. The silver comes off and I don't like that when paying $36 with shipping.
I love the thrive mascara, it's the only mascara that makes me look like I have lashes on the lower lashline
swum is such a weird and fun sounding word.
Half Baked also has one. Would love to see a bunch of these lower priced/drugstore options. Pt 2??
How about the Clinique tubing mascara?
Your eye color is stunning!❤
I just tuned in, I just found you BUT thank you, thank you, thank you for keeping “cruelty free” in mind AND talking about it. We must stop animal testing. 🙏 I’m going to head right over to your video on the topic as soon as I finish watching this one. 🌼
those veneers though
I know this is a dirty brand but when L’Oréal first came out with their tubing product it was fantastic and held a consistent texture from application to removal then they changed it. My last tube it dried down hard and very stiff and didn’t perform like the original.
Maybe you can tell my why eyelash curlers don’t work like they did 30/40 years ago … yes I’m showing my age.
I'm guessing the Maybelline Sky High isn't on the list bc it's not cruelty free, but it's an affordable/drugstore option that performs really well.